California Media & First Amendment Lawyer & Newspaper of General Circulation Attorney
California Legal Advertising Adjudication Lawyer Representing Adjudicated Newspapers of Record – Petitioners and Contestants in Los Angeles, Orange County, San Diego, Riverside, Palm Springs, San Bernardino, Palo Alto, San Jose, Santa Barbara, Redding, Oakland, and Long Beach
In California, official legal notices and legal advertising can be published only in a newspaper of general circulation adjudicated by a court of law. Whether a publication chooses to seek adjudication as a newspaper under the traditional criteria of Government Code Section 6000 or the alternative criteria of Government Code Section 6008, the publisher would be wise to choose an attorney skilled in this niche area of law. Indeed, many newspapers find themselves in contact with attorneys with no experience in this specialized area of law with traps for the unwary. This is all too common as there are only a handful of experts on newspaper adjudications in California.
In fact, this area of law is so uncommon that most judges who rule on these petitions have never addressed this area of law in their many decades in the law. In turn, the courts are likely to trust the reasonable statutory interpretations set forth by a counselor with experience in newspaper of general circulation litigation.
This is where Talkov Law will make the difference. Indeed, we have handled dozens of newspaper of general circulation petitions on behalf of petitioners and newspaper of general circulation contestants alike. Often times, we have petitions pending in multiple courts throughout California at any given time. The efficiency and knowledge we provide is to the benefit of our clients, and to the detriment of any competing newspaper that may seek to contest a newspaper of general circulation petition.
Experience will make the difference in this area of law, which has generated only about 100 published cases in the 100-plus-year history of this area of law. Hiring an attorney who understands the nuances of each of these 100 cases and the application of those cases where the facts may present a unique challenge will mean that your position is clearly understood by the court.
Even further, our experience means an efficient result. It is not truly possible for an attorney to read and understand each of the 100 cases in this area of law at minimal client expense unless they have previously represented newspapers in seeking adjudication. With experience on behalf of petitions and contestants, we know the questions that have been answered and those that have not, ensuring effective advocacy for your newspaper.
We have represented newspapers of national, regional and local prominence throughout California. This means we have obtained or opposed adjudication orders throughout California. Judges in each of these counties have trusted our experience. Indeed, Attorney Scott Talkov has led a workshop for the California Newspaper Publishers Association. We are confident that you will see the value in bringing Talkov Law onto your team.
Our Newspaper of General Circulation Practices
Our practices for newspapers throughout the state include the following:
- Petitions for adjudication as a newspaper of general circulation
- Contests to petitions for adjudication as a newspaper of general circulation
- Name change petitions for adjudicated newspapers
- Contests to the status of an adjudicated newspaper of general circulation
- Petitions under the established criteria of California Government Code section 6000
- Petitions under the alternative criteria of California Government Code section 6008
- Questions concerning the effect of an adjudication as a newspaper of general circulation
- Inquiries concerning the impact of a pre-1923 adjudication as a newspaper of general circulation
- Requirements for government agencies to publish in newspapers of general circulation in California
- Competition between newspapers of general circulation
Newspaper of General Circulation FAQs
- I am a free publication with no paid subscribers. Can I still qualify as a newspaper of general circulation?
Government Code Section 6000 requires a “bona fide subscription list of paying subscribers.” A list is “bona fide” if it is a “real, actual, genuine subscription list.” In re Herman (1920) 183 Cal. 153, 164.
Effectively, the court disregards all circulation other than the paid subscriber list. Accordingly, many newspapers generate a paid subscriber list to comply with the law in advance of requesting adjudication. Developing a paid subscriber list is often easier than many newspaper publishers imagine. We can guide you through this process prior to applying for adjudication.
- Does the same process apply to digital publications? If digital media has paid subscribers, can it be qualified?
A qualifying newspaper must be “printed” at least weekly under Gov. Code 6008 or “regularly” under Gov. Code 6000 (every other week or monthly) in the county, city or other political jurisdiction where adjudication is sought for at least one year preceding the petition. Government Code section 6000 requires a newspaper to be “printed” and Government Code section 6008 sets forth that it applies to “newspapers,” not to blogs.
The trick for digital publications to become adjudicated is to publish something in paper, no matter how small it may be, and to obtain a bona fide subscriber list, for which the law imposes no numerical minimum number of subscribers. Our attorneys can assist you in meeting this requirement to allow for adjudication as a newspaper of general circulation.
- Is there a minimum subscriber requirement?
No. Government Code Section 6000 requires a “bona fide subscription list of paying subscribers,” while Government Code Section 6008 requires the list to be both bona fide and substantial. However, no court has ever set forth a specific number of paying subscribers that must be on this list. Our attorneys can help you determine an appropriate minimum number of subscribers in consideration of the number of people in the circulation area and the likely number of subscribers of other newspaper of general circulation in that area. Note that even the most successful newspapers only have a few percent of the population as subscribers in their coverage area, so something less than this should easily suffice.
- We are adjudicated in one city/county. Can we still petition for adjudication in other areas?
Yes. A newspaper must be “‘published’ at least weekly in county or city where adjudication is sought for at least one year preceding the petition for adjudication” under Government Code Section 6000 and must have an office in the city where adjudication is sought under Government Code Section 6008.
Accordingly, the easiest way to obtain a second adjudication is to use a different name for the publication when it is circulated in the second area where adjudication is sought. For example, the Los Angeles Times could establish a newspaper by the name of the Orange County Times or San Francisco Times with similar (or, potentially, identical) content. Such sister publications are common in legal advertising.
- How much can we charge for legal notices? Can we charge our own rate or is there a limit/guideline to how much we can charge?
There is no limit to the amount that a newspaper can charge for legal advertising. However, as a practical matter, if legal advertisers can lawfully use a cheaper publication, and can locate that publication, they may decide to do so. Often times, newspapers with a monopoly in a particular jurisdiction charge considerably higher rates due to the inability of legal advertisers to publish elsewhere.
- I am now working from home. Does this affect my status?
No. Government Code 6025 provides that “All publications made in a newspaper during the period it was adjudged to be a newspaper of general circulation are valid and sufficient.”
However, a competitor could file a motion to vacate an adjudication based on alleged non-compliance under Government Code Section 6024. They could allege non-compliance with the requirement under Government Code Section 6008 that a newspaper has its “principal office of publication” in the city or county to the extent the home office is not in the city or county. They could also allege non-compliance with the requirement under Government Code Section 6000 that the newspaper be “published” from the city or county to the extent the home office is not in the city of county.
However, there are arguments that these rules could not be applied to conclude that a home office is prohibited. Even further, motions to vacate adjudications are rare, so the odds that any party could ever raise the issue of a home office as a basis to vacate an adjudication is far fetched, even if is possible.
- How often must I publish to qualify?
A qualifying newspaper must be “printed” at least weekly under Gov. Code 6008 or “regularly” under Gov. Code 6000 (every other week or monthly)
- Does my publication need to be in English?
No. The court in In re La Opinion (1970) 10 Cal.App.3d 1012, 1018 explained that: “A newspaper printed in a foreign language does not, for that reason alone, fail to meet the language of the statute so read. ” This means that “newspaper published in a foreign language may be considered to be a newspaper of general circulation.” 46 Cal. Jur. 3d Newspapers and Press Associations § 10 (citing In re La Opinion).
Contact a California Newspaper of General Circulation Attorney Today
Becoming an adjudicated newspaper in California is the key to financial success. This way, your publication can obtain lucrative city legal advertising, trustee sales and probate notices, among other legal notices. Once your publication is adjudicated, you’ll wonder how your business operated before you were entitled to run legal advertising.
If you’re interested in learning more about adjudication as a newspaper of general circulation, contesting an adjudication, the effect of your adjudication, or contesting the propriety of legal advertising, call Talkov Law today at (844) 4-TALKOV (825568)or contact us online for a free analysis of your publication.
Talkov Law provides business attorneys in Los Angeles, Orange County, San Diego, San Bernardino, Riverside, Palm Springs, Palo Alto, San Jose, Sacramento, Santa Barbara, Redding, Oakland, Long Beach, and surrounding areas.