Constructive Trust in California
What is a Constructive Trust?
A constructive trust is a remedy used by a court to compel a person who has property they are not justly entitled to to transfer it to the intended beneficiary as determined by the court.
How can I get a Constructive Trust?
California law provides that a constructive trust is created where a defendant takes a property by fraud, accident, mistake, undue influence, the violation of a trust or other wrongful act. California Civil Code §§ 2223, 2224. By court order, a constructive trust imposes trustee status on the defendant. This means that they can hold the property but they can’t benefit from it.
A court creates a fictional or “constructive” trust by recognizing that legal title is held by one person (the wrongdoer) but demands the wrongdoer hold that title as a trustee of a trust created for the beneficiary–the rightful owner. The title-holder’s only duty is to give the property to the rightful owner.
The following must be shown for the court to impose a constructive trust: “(1) the existence of a res (property or some interest in property)’ (2) the right of a complaining party to that res; and (3) some wrongful acquisition or detention of the res by another party who is not entitled to it.” Communist Party v Valencia, Inc. (1995) 35 CA4th 980, 990.
Importantly, if no res exists, then there is nothing over which the complaining party can obtain a constructive trust.
Constructive Trust Example
Sarah withdrew $10,000 from her bank account to buy a car. Sarah put the money in an envelope in her room. Sarah’s boyfriend, Jim, finds the money and uses it to buy a motorcycle in his name. Jim has wrongfully taken and used money that belongs to Sarah. Jim no longer has the $10,000. However, Sarah can show the court that she withdrew the money from her account and that Jim took it and bought a motorcycle. Through a method called “tracing” the court can find that Jim has title to the motorcycle but must give the motorcycle to Sarah even though the $10,000 that was Sarah’s is no longer in cash form.
Importantly, if Jim had taken that motorcycle and sold it to his brother for just $5,000 and Jim’s brother thought Jim was the owner of the bike, then Sarah can no longer get a constructive trust over the motorcycle because Jim’s brother would be a bona fide purchaser. Sarah can still get a constructive trust over the proceeds (thee $5,000) from the sale of the bike from Jim to his brother. If Jim had told his brother before he sold him the motorcycle that he took Sarah’s $10,000 to buy it, then Jim’s brother would not be a bona fide purchaser and Sarah would still be able to get a constructive trust over the motorcycle.
Questions About Trusts? Contact a Trust, Estate & Probate Attorney in California Today!
Our attorneys serve clients throughout Los Angeles, Orange County, San Diego, Riverside, Palm Springs, San Bernardino, Palo Alto, and San Jose.
The Trusts, Estate, & Probate Litigation Attorneys at Talkov Law practice in the areas of: